steampunk as subculture

[Cephias]

After consideration, this is what I can conclude from my observations:
1.  A major theme among those of the Steampunk persuasion are those that greatly enjoy building and changing things to fit their personal taste. (A backlash against todays prepackaged society perhaps)

2. Many people exist as a Steampunk (or some variation on that theme) but do no realize that there are like-minded individuals like them out there, or that they were indeed "Steampunks".

As such, most come to this subculture with their own particular "brand".  Having come, and found out that there is indeed something called Steampunk, they do what comes naturally and modify/change it to fit their own tastes and aesthetics.  Thus it would be fruitless to try to proclaim a rigid set of rules to what exactly is Steampunk as most individuals like to bend the rules anyways.  There are those who are interested in dress and attire, there are those interested in gadgets and gizmo's, and those further still interested in the literature, and the thought behind it.  However, we all share a similar theme, and find inspiration in eachother.  I liken it to the Zen concept of Dharma transmission.  We all share a dream/vision but none of us can define it very well because we only know it when we see it.  There is just that spark when we all stand in front of some boiler, or a model of an airship and just point and smile to one another, sharing the glow of that shared glimpse of our vision.  We are not some great series of identical microchips all blinking to the same pulse, we are the great cogs, gears, and springs of some great machine; some big, some small, but we all work off of one another.  When the one of our minds whir with the energy of discovery and inspiration, it will not be long before the whole machine will be alive and clanking along.  Call that machine "Steampunk" if you will.  But it's energy will power bulbs (and valves) across the world.

Well then, thats enough of a sermon for me.  Terribly sorry for being so forward and all.  I'll be going now.

[Honky-Tonk Dragon]

Well said, dear sir!

[Josh of Vernian Process]

Well yes, I think that is pretty much the conclusion we've all come to. I still stand by my statement that Steampunk has a solid definition, and that it shouldn't be changed to fit an individuals take on it. Of course individuals can have their own ideas of what Steampunk is, but when those ideas are presented as fact to the public, it creates great confusion.

We all have our own preferences when it comes to the Steampunk genre, but we all also must agree on a solid meaning for it. I think the one that Cory stated over in the Steampunk isn't Punk thread is the most solid one I can think of. Simply the idea of Victorian inspired Anachronism (which can be set in other time periods).

Oh, and please refer to it as a culture, not a subculture. A minor technicality, but one that saves a lot of unneeded debate.

P.S. No need for anyone else to debate this post, just needed to add my thoughts (which will remain the same no matter what anyone else has to say on the subject).

[Dreamsmith]

Wh..wait..wait a.. what's this?

We've come to some sort of tenuous agreement? I see nothing to contradict, nothing to... to... debate?

The debate is over?

:Gets off soapbox and starts the long walk home:

Just joking, assuredly. I am most happy that, once we get the terminology out of the way, and the basic semantics, that even if we don't all agree, per se, we can still all get along and respect each other.

And that is a sign, dear folks, of maturity within the community, if not a mature community... waith, that doesn't mean quite what I want it to... It's just we're a "young" community...

Oh, never mind. I'm much more eloquent when arguing...   

As always, I am your humble servant,
--the Dreamsmith

[Honky-Tonk Dragon]

Thank you to all who contributed to this thread and the "steampunk isn't punk" thread.
Though perhaps a tedious process at first, I think these discussions have been vital to help us create a broadbased, tolerant community.
If someone who just discovered this board had the patience to slog through all of both of them, I think they would come away with a good sense of what the board is all about... and be saved the indignity of inadvertently bruising feelings and rifling feathers.

[kiskolou]

Wow. Happy endings. I'm glad to see my thread ending like this (although i'm not sure if it's fair to call it my thread anymore...). Maybe we should lock this, but keep it as a historical document?

[Josh of Vernian Process]

I think it should be locked, and then stickied.

[Honky-Tonk Dragon]

I think it should be locked, and then stickied.

seconded.

[Jake von Slatt]

I think it should be locked, and then stickied.

seconded.

Aye!

[Stirling_Cycle]

Steampunk as a Sub-Culture, I'm starting to believe it's coming into it's own as a culture in itself. Just as the American and Commonwealth nations have come from the UK, but they have have developed their own cultures, seperated by a common language (i.e. I do say, good sir, What is a billabong?).

I guess you can say I'm a recovering Rivit and over the last couple of years have been disillusioned with the scene(been enthralled since 1988 c.e.). Tired of the politics and elitist attitudes from countless hot topic clones, I've yearned for something with more substanance. Steampunk, varied as it may seem, has a rich literary, cultural and philosophical tradition. Whether your are a collier, adventurer or Aristocrat, everyone seems to be on equal footing. Politic's? Sure every culture and sub-genre has it. This is unavoidable. As a whole the politics is more tongue in cheek and never seems to get more serious than "No, no, I'm sorry to say, Darjeeling is a much more sopisticated tea than Twinnings". Because, I believe, in this modern culture of convenience and egocentric behaviour, we understand you can get further by practicing good manners and think beyond the white man's burden (of other sub cultures). So whether you are into the pomp or the circumstance you know you will always fit in and be accepted, unless you are a total bludger or a fine wirer.

I, myself, don't have the couter to wear the dunnage. None the less, I still feel a part of the culture and hope to develop it more. -_Q


Cheers!

[Tinkergirl]

And with that, with three people calling for this thread to be honourably locked, I will do so.

Quite a rollercoaster ride, but a very interesting one indeed.  Glad it turned out well in the end.

^_Q